Why was Michelangelo hired/allowed by the pope to paint god photos on the ceiling of the Sistine chapel, while it is forbidden to create an image of God by the ten commandments?
Not all people interprets it that way, although. And in fact, you only quoted element of that commandment. The complete commandment is:
You shall not make for your self an impression in the kind of something in heaven over or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. You shall not bow down to them or worship them for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, punishing the young children for the sin of the mothers and fathers to the 3rd and fourth generation of these who loathe me, but displaying love to a thousand generations of those who really like me and maintain my commandments.
Painting god photos
There are various ways of decoding this. The strictest interpretation is the a single adopted by the strictest Muslim sects: a total ban on photographs of everything in the true world. That’s why so a lot Islamic artwork is summary.
However, most Christian theologians don’t interpret it that way. First of all, the term translated by the NIV as “image” really refers to some thing carved out of wooden or stone — the more traditional “graven image” is in fact much more precise listed here. But even that’s not all there is to it, since the Previous Testament is complete of God-approved graven pictures (the Ten Commandments are positioned within the Ark of the Covenant, developed to God’s very own technical specs such as carved angels).
Secondly, the 1st two sentences most likely must be one particular — when the Previous Testimony was prepared, punctuation hadn’t been invented, and sometimes it’s challenging to inform where a single sentence ends and the next starts.
The most most likely interpretation is: “You shall not carve out of wooden or stone something that appears like everything that exists and then worship it.” In other phrases, this is a commandment in opposition to idolotry, the producing of synthetic gods and worshipping them. Israel was strange at the time in not worshipping statues: they claimed that this was simply because their God existed for actual, whereas other “gods” were basically lumps of wood. So, by buy of God himself, really don’t worship lumps of wood — it clarifies the “I am a jealous God” bit.
So, most Christians interpret this commandment as a ban on idol worship. You can make god photos of something you like, as long as you don’t worship them.
God photos painting is not really God
The straightforward answer is “different religions interpret the bible differently”. Also maintain in mind that the sentence you quoted up there is one particular variation of translation of a translation of a translation.
To get far more distinct, the photographs painted, along with icons and other representations are just that – representations. They’re not really god photos. They cannot be, simply because we do not know what God seems like.
Naturally some religions, and some factions of the very same faith may possibly disagree on the interpretations. For instance, there are some Jewish orthodox painters who say that given that God produced us in His image, you shouldn’t paint men and women. One particular of them is well-known for portray planks of wooden wherever people need to be.
There is much disagreement on this matter. Some Muslims (specifically historically) are a-okay with pictures of Mohammed. Some branches of Greek Orthodox Christianity say you can make two-dimensional photographs of God, but not 3-dimensional kinds. The Amish don’t consider you ought to make god photos of any individual, so they really don’t have pictures of them selves taken and don’t put faces on children’s dolls.
Painting god photos are not idols
The word that the really terrible NIV translates into god photos is far more properly translated into “idol”.
If you read a small additional, Exodus twenty five:eighteen states, You shall make two cherubim of gold, make them of hammered function at the two ends of the mercy seat.” This is explicitly instructing Moses to make an image of a point in heaven, so plainly your interpretation of 20:4 is overly broad.
That is not what the commandment is referring to. It’s addressing idolatry, the worship of earthly factors alternatively of God. It doesn’t say you can’t paint God. Just that you shouldn’t worship the portray or the artwork, you should worship God.
What lacking from this particular translation is “graven graphic.” What it truly signifies is not to develop idols to worship.
I.e. no large gold statues of a sun god. It ties into the 1st Commandment of getting no other guys. No paganism and no idolatry.
No there is not! Claiming there are various ways to interpret the words of you know who, is why the spiritual get absent with and justify the crap they pull.
The Roman Catholic Church eliminated the 2nd commandment (the one particular you mention), and break up the tenth commandment into two commandments in purchase to get again to ten.